All this after the fact stuff is interesting. Apparently both IGN and Gamespot agree that BioShock (Xbox360) was the game of the show. Crysis (PC) won both graphics awards. Nintendo's Wii controller won for hardware.. and they said the lack of anything playable for PS3 was really disappointing. Assasin's Creed (PS3) won action game of the show for IGN even though it was not even playable lmao. Other than that their opinions differed on what games were the best. I haven't read any of the other online sites yet as far as their opinions on E3 though.
IGN's E3 crap
http://games.ign.com/articles/709/709355p1.html
Gamespot's
http://www.gamespot.com/features/6151435/index.htm