One more note for anybody wondering, because it can happen, what to do if one or both of your tanks get the first prey (meaning they can't take the second):
PLD - Hallowed Ground to survive either the first or second hit.
DRK - Same with Living Dead, but since Living Dead is a pain in the ass you can copy WAR strat:
WAR - Cooldowns, Stoneskin, Adlo, etc the FIRST prey. As long as they take 0 damage they won't get the debuff that make's the second hit kill you.
This means you can actually cheese the mechanic entirely by shielding both of your tanks enough to not take any damage from the first prey, but it's difficult to grab the prey and get into position in time due to the slippery prey debuff.