well been camping this for 1 of my best ingame friends now for about 3months being 0/37(?) maybe more this jp nin who always camps it told us....

_________________
I beat FF. Maats Cap is over rated.




BLMAF2:3/5
RDMAF2:2/5
BSTAF2:5/5(lies!hi2ublacksage)

thief knife sucks

it's luxury++ item! :O

and TH adds a % to that 1% of drop. That TH% being -1000% :P
Im 0/79 btw ^^. So if the JP is right that means 21 more kills! cept I havnt been to that camp in like 3months cause it's boring as hell.

_________________

I don't even think it's really worth it. TH seems to be so damn random in effectiveness that I swear it doesn't even work most of the time.

lol every1 expects to notice TH2s effectiveness immediatly, it takes a while to notice its effect its maybe a 15% increase on drops if so less but i notice this alot in rolanberry fields w/farming threads/cuttings

_________________
I beat FF. Maats Cap is over rated.




BLMAF2:3/5
RDMAF2:2/5
BSTAF2:5/5(lies!hi2ublacksage)

Wow that sucks... to much work for crap. i think....


But do what ever floats your boat :P

_________________
**Life is a game,it's ment to be played**

RNG/NIN║RNG/NIN(Future Goal)║NIN/WAR(Future Goal)

Yeah, this shit is retarded. Most of the time, the NM isn't even camped by THFs but by NINs, RNGs, etc. who want to sell for gil. Needs to be tagged RARE/EX. The JP player in your pic actually has a 75THF but is camping as NIN for claiming.

_________________

yeah he does he has 1 already,im camping it for thf last time gilsellers claimed it i brought a jug and binded it nexty to them :P mnk voked it and then he died <3 throat stab :D and whm..got ownd

ask milamber she can vouch i mpk any1 for no reason (i swear not trying to start a flame)

_________________
I beat FF. Maats Cap is over rated.




BLMAF2:3/5
RDMAF2:2/5
BSTAF2:5/5(lies!hi2ublacksage)

Not because a JP says something he has to be right >_> Just because drop rate is still retarded with TH2 doesn't mean chance to get isnt much better.

_________________



Main: War75/Sam63/Blm71/Rng45
Sub: Nin37/Thf37/Whm37/Mnk30
Three nation: Done Zilart: Done CoP: Done

yup exactly. it's such a rare drop it should be rare/ex. Same with Ebow I think. Th1 2 3 4 5million or w/e is just random. I see TH as just being an added % for the drop. As if everyone in your pt gets a /random for an item to drop and every level of Th adds an imaginary person to your pt. And yeah what kay said. Who cares if he's jp or w/e. They dont know everything about the game and even SE wont tell anyone how TH works so I doubt he knows. TH effects all drops. to say it doesnt work on Sozu is like saying it doesnt work on Kirin And yeah it's annoying to see ninjas and rangers camping it but heh w/e.

_________________

still

lani come camp w/me :D we can zone bonze for no reason to!

_________________
I beat FF. Maats Cap is over rated.




BLMAF2:3/5
RDMAF2:2/5
BSTAF2:5/5(lies!hi2ublacksage)

I know people who got it in 2 kills and then theres people who are 50+ with no such luck. Aside from Yagudo necklaces and Beehive Chips i really dont see much of a difference in drops with TH2

_________________

lol you dont farm much then :P

_________________
I beat FF. Maats Cap is over rated.




BLMAF2:3/5
RDMAF2:2/5
BSTAF2:5/5(lies!hi2ublacksage)

i farm beehive chips, silk, tree cuttings and clot plasma.

Stealing is such a better way to farm if you're a thief anywho, but thats neither here nor there

_________________

platinum coins and gold coins @ newton yes please :D

_________________
I beat FF. Maats Cap is over rated.




BLMAF2:3/5
RDMAF2:2/5
BSTAF2:5/5(lies!hi2ublacksage)

diablo2 magicfind > ff11 treasure hunter

_________________
RIP Shiloh - I'll never forget ya

Yes!

_________________
[In Yarr we trust.]

I've found that treasure hunter+ really helps in dynamis.. but maybe it's just my imagination. I had one dynamis.. we had a thf with like every piece of th+ gear on, and it seemed like every kill he made, another piece of af would drop.

But it's just another one of those ffxi secrets that no one will ever know the real answers to and just continue to bicker about over internet forums for all eternity

_________________

thats amusing because I have seen a post by someone whose set up an all BLM dynamis LS and they brought along 2 thf's just cause. One with Thiefs knife and one without.

When they went the only AF to drop were 2 assassin's bonnets. They said the only thing they noticed was an increase in singles dropping.

That and from what I understand Treasure Hunter doesnt help with rare/ex items.

then again its all friggin hearsay.

_________________

It's just that there's too many factors to consider (time, day, moon phase, number of folks in the zone, time you've been in zone, equipment, etc etc, prolly a bunch of factors no one's ever even considered before) to ever come up with undisputable results about how it helps if it all, I personally have noticed an increase in normal items in regular zones, and I do believe it to help with nm/hnm/dynamis drops, but that's more speculation and my experience than based on any kind of hard evidence.

_________________

TH4 sucks ballz. It just looks nice

_________________

FTW!

_________________
If only you all had a large Proton-Enhanced Nuclear Induction Spectroscopy machine like I do.

updated......................

Thiefs Knife.......O
GOT IT!

_________________
I beat FF. Maats Cap is over rated.




BLMAF2:3/5
RDMAF2:2/5
BSTAF2:5/5(lies!hi2ublacksage)

(Congratulations!)

_________________

OMG Shunjiro IRL